Opinion: Confessions of a Lifelong California Republican

Letter to the editor: I would love to see the party return to its roots.

By Diana Stephens
When I turned 18 in 1977, I read both the Republican and Democratic platforms before registering to vote. The Democratic platform made me feel as though I had the weight of our whole society on my shoulders. I much preferred the Republican pull yourself up by your bootstraps philosophy, as well as the desire to keep government fiscally responsible and out of people’s business.

The next year the anti-abortion plank was added, which felt strangely invasive, but I chose to fight that battle from within the party by becoming a Republican for Choice. Sonograms soon made it clear that women would never be able to use abortions as a form of birth control, but after suffering all night through a miscarriage, I arrived at the doctor’s office and was treated by being given an abortion. I was grateful to my doctor and cannot imagine that there should be laws passed to prevent such care.

Time wore on and Republicans seemed to align themselves with so many nonsensical positions that I began to seriously question my choice of party. The hidden costs of pollution on the environment, other species, and our own health seemed excessive compared with those of responsible stewardship. As a classroom teacher I was faced with the possibility of being forced to report students to the authorities. Fortunately, due to the eventual defeat of Proposition 187 in the courts, I never faced that dilemma. Immigration reform makes sense and has been needed for a long time, but some compromise will be required and I have not heard enough of that on the right side of the political spectrum.

Today Republicans have mixed politics with religion as if they had never heard of the separation of church and state. Our over-dependence on moneyed interests makes me wish for a separation of business and state as well. One would think that fiscal prudence would occasionally override neoconservative tendencies, but no, we started two wars without any plan to pay for either of them, only one of which might have been justified. Both parties spend too much money; Republicans just want to spend it on supporting the industrial military complex. Another concern is the continued dismissal of empirical data that is deemed inconvenient, say, regarding global warming or evolution. This “dumbing down” of the Republican Party, as is witnessed daily on talk radio, is outright offensive at times.

So, what is a lifelong Republican to do? It is tempting to throw in the towel and register as an Independent, but I’ve come this far.  Maybe California Republicans, who now claim fewer than 30 percent of the registered voters in the state, should consider leading a campaign to recapture the party from the extremists who have taken it over. Those radicals are a minority after all, and we would receive much more support from the moderates, women, and minorities that were so important in the recent election. I would love to see the Republican Party return to its roots and stand for true fiscal responsibility and keeping government out of our bedrooms as well as our boardrooms.

Diana Stephens

Chris Nicholson November 13, 2012 at 09:37 PM
@Amanda: It's also called an attempt at humor. When I said "blame" I meant "attribute the outcome" and not an assignment of culpability. I think this is clear from the context of my other remarks in the same post. And, @B&R: I also hate it when people get personal and talk about having "many black gay handicapped friends who suffer PTSD." I don't care about your race or gender, I just care about your ideas. My position is that the GOP has not evolved with changing demographics. I find it regrettable that the populace is so closely aligned with identity buckets that seemingly should not dictate political leanings, but that is the statistical reality of the world we live in. Given that, it is foolish to ignore race, gender, etc., when discussing political strategy. Is it racist to observe that virtually all black voters voted for Obama? Whatever your answer, it is silly to ignore the fact if you want to predict the outcome of elections.
Born and Raised November 13, 2012 at 09:42 PM
Amanda, I didn't take the bait. I pissed on it and left the trap alone.
Kenny November 13, 2012 at 10:36 PM
Mr. Nicholson - I was surprised to hear that my name was mentioned. How kind of you to think of me. While I still check-in with the Lamorinda site, my focus remains parenting blogs which the Lamorinda site doesn't offer. However, many other Patch sites do & you can find me cruising around those & commenting with my standard ID. If this site ever picks up a parenting blog, I'm sure you'll see me back. Other than parenting blogs, I like to leave commenting to those far more invested in the topics. Take care.
lisa November 14, 2012 at 01:21 AM
I see a lot of this or that about the Hispanic vote. Although Catholics tend to be anti-abortion, most believe MORE strongly in helping the poor and needy....something the suffering lower/middle income folks have to generally contend with. GOP has the opposite view. Sorry, social issues are not going to help the GOP...ever..in terms of the Hispanic view of life. I grew up in a heavily Hispanic/Filipino/diverse/minority City in the Bay Area and the GOP has never benefited the Latinos or anyone I've ever known in their every day lives. The GOP still and will always benefit citizens that have always had a huge leg up and/or parental help to begin with.
Marcia Nelson April 28, 2013 at 10:13 PM
This woman is a phony. She was/is not a Republican, much less a lifelong one. Just a typical lying Democrat masquerading as a republican. This is a favorite meme of the left. I've never seen a "lifelong Democrat" claim to be, for the first time ever (!) voting Republican in an election. Probably because it's lame and fools no one. It certainly won't keep them from trying. Over and over and over again.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »